3/11/2008

To Cast the First Stone

I try not to comment too often on news stories, but sometimes the issue is so compelling I can’t resist. The precipitous demise of NY Governor Eliot Spitzer is a case in point. While I find his actions lamentable, I still feel for the man. To be in a position of such power, to be an admired husband and father, to be widely respected for one’s moral strength--and then to risk and lose so much for so little, is remarkably tragic—and remarkably human. If a man of such accomplishment and presumed strength of character can so quickly bring himself to naught, what should we lesser mortals expect of ourselves? It’s easy to condemn the guy, to find his behavior contemptible, to laugh at the irony of his crime in the face of his notorious self-righteousness, but I ask this: Is there a person out there (of the three or four who read this blog) who has never done a bad thing? Don’t we all have a skeleton or two in our closet that if discovered would cause us no small amount of embarrassment, humiliation and shame? C’mon, fess up. I know, Spitzer’s a leader, a parent, a former lawman, a role model to young people, etc., and as such his sins loom preternaturally large. But he’s human, like you and me. Does he have any more responsibility to do the right thing than we have? Let’s face it—he’s going to pay in more ways than we can name, and he’ll be paying for the rest of his life. If he’s done what he’s accused of, he’s got a burden to bear that would cripple the best of us. So put yourself in his shoes and walk a mile or two. You may find you can forgive him a little, and maybe you can forgive yourself, too.

6 comments:

Bill Simpson said...

eliot was a self-righteous egotistical jerkwad before we found out he had to pay for nooky on the side. most of these pols with that kind of power usually come by it free. word is he has a loopy weewee.

and so he's also a hypocrite. big deal?

i think it'll be cool to see NY run by a blind black dude. now that is worth a blog entry.

Doogman2 said...

I DO feel sympathy for Spitzer for all the reasons you mention, Chuck, and then some. I can hardly imagine the Klong (def: a sudden rush of shit to the heart) he must have experienced when he realized his lust had gone public at the speed of light. The bottom surely dropped out of his stomach as if from a hangman's trapdoor.

The era of the press turning a blind eye is long gone. Not because of a heightened sense of morality in our society, but because titillation sells. Don't want any other news organization to get the scoop whilst we hang back.

As a former prosecutor, he knows how sting operations work. He understands wiretaps. His precautions (Client #9, etc.) were
clearly insufficient. Was it hubris that caused him to think it would all turn out OK?

Forgiveness? As a "confirmed" non-believer, I believe that not being crushed by massive guilt starts with the ability to forgive one's self - on a frequent and regular basis if need be. I realize that I have both virtues and failings and thrive on the challenge to keep them in daily balance. However, Mr. Spitzer has much bigger problems than I would under similar circumstances, because of his prominence and a very wide circle of friends and acquaintances, many of whom will see no other alternative than to publicly shun him. Unfortunately, tragically, he's toast.

chuck said...

Thanks for the thoughtful posts, Doogman and Simmy. Now that Spitzer's resigned, the State of NY will be picking up the pieces for a goodly while.
I think Doogman's question about what made him think things would turn out OK is one worth pondering. It's the question of motivation. Why would a person with so much to lose risk it all on something apparently so insignificant? Is this a form of mental illness? Is it the inability to project the consequences? Foolhardiness? Assholeishness? Belief in one's invulnerability? Love of risk, perhaps addiction to risk? Sex obsession? I don't know. But we all do it to some degree, yet seldom with such devastating consequences as the possible result. I think it's more than being a hypocrite. People who succeed at that level are different than "regular" people. Bigger ideas, bigger egos, bigger risk-takers, bigger psychos.

Anonymous said...

Jeez fellas, the guy wanted to get laid. And apparently thought he had the whole secrecy thing locked tight. Sex is a strong motivator. For every jackass pol who's caught, there's many more meeting tonight with their $1,000 sweetheart.
Jim

Sara said...

Yeah, right here in Nanaimo--where prositution and pimping is legal.

chuck said...

Nah. If he just wanted sex he could have called an escort service and paid cash. This is a guy who understood not only the workings of the sex industry but the intricacies of electronic money transfer. He would have known he was at risk, and he would have understood his level of risk. There was a guy on the News Hour tonight who had an interesting explanation: Spitzer is addicted--to sex or risk or both. Like an alcoholic or a drug addict, he needs treatment for his addiction. The other thing this guy said was that when people have as much power as Spitzer had, they tend to delude themselves into believing they can get away with anything.